|
Rudder Stuffing Box
As long as I've owned Sarah she has had a wet bilge.
In that time I've tried to find the source of the leak or leaks in
vain. The leaks were so slight I could find no evidence of where
the water was coming from. The leaks were slight enough that I
rarely noticed the bilge pump coming on, but no matter how dry I
pumped the bilge within a week it would be completely wet again.
I thought I could detect a leak from the propeller shaft stuffing
box and I replaced that with a PSS shaft seal. A marine surveyor
who had done work on the boat for the previous owner thought it was
possible that a boat yard may have set the boat down on the aft
portion of the keel, which is hollow. He thought the fiberglass may
have cracked enough to allow in a small trickle of water. Before I
left for Florida in 2004 I had the lower portion of the keel
re-glassed.
All to no
avail. The bilge constantly had an inch or less of water in it.
While living on board in Florida over the winter of 2004-2005 I
began to notice that the bilge pump came on at least once every two
or three days. This was more often than I had noticed in the past.
It would come on even more often during rainy weather, which told me
at least one of the leaks was on deck.
While
sailing across the Atlantic to Portugal I noticed that the frequency
of bilge pump activity was increasing. By the time we were
approaching the coast of Portugal the pump was coming on every 2 - 3
hours. During this period we had no rain.
Now at least the flow of water
was sufficient to leave evidence. I could see a very slight leak
coming from under the engine pan. This meant the leak was coming
from somewhere under the cockpit. That left the rudder stuffing box
as the prime suspect.
I could
not verify that the stuffing box was leaking because I could not see
it. When originally built this Pearson 424 provided adequate, if
not comfortable, access to this stuffing box. However, the primary
access was through the stern lazzarette, which on Sarah houses the
generator installed by the previous owner. The P.O. as installed a
small battery box in the port sail locker, which blocked access from
that locker. In the first year of my ownership I installed the
drive unit for the autopilot in the starboard sail locker. So all
of the normal access points for the stuffing box are blocked on
Sarah.
Once
secured in the marina in Cascais, PT the leak reduced to the same
amount of bilge pump activity as the previous winter in Florida. So
it was obvious that the leak was greater when Sarah was underway -
further pointing to the rudder stuffing box.
Over that winter I started
planning how I could get at the stuffing box to either tighten or
re-pack it. The solution arrived in the person of my wee welsh
friend, Martin. Martin could fit down into the lockers in a way I
never will and at least he could see the stuffing box. He confirmed
that it was indeed leaking and that there were ample threads on the
fitting to allow it to be tightened significantly. So we probably
didn't have to re-pack it at this time.
About this
time I was able to get my digital camera down into the area of the
stuffing box and took the two pictures above, right and left. In
the top picture you can see the amount of thread below the lock nut
(bottom nut). The picture below on the left shows the moisture on
the top of the stuffing box. This was at least one source the bilge
water on Sarah.
Our first
problem was to find a wrench of sufficient size to work the nuts on
the stuffing box. We measured the nut with a micrometer to be about
2-1/2". I have a Channel Locks adjustable wrench that is large
enough. However that type of wrench would be difficult if not
impossible to use on the nut. Through one of the service shops at
the marina I acquired a large pipe wrench, shown in the picture on
the right.
Even with that wrench and
Martin's small size it was still not possible to effectively work on
the stuffing box. We finally removed the port side pulley for the
steering cable and Martin could squeeze in between the rudder stop
and the generator battery box to get the wrench on the nuts with
some leverage.
The result is the picture on
the right. The stuffing box has been tightened up about one full
turn and fitting cleaned up with a wire brush. As of now there is
no detectable leak through the rudder stuffing box.
If it
starts to leak again it will finally be time to repack the fitting.
Hopefully that is a year or two off.
Before
departing Lago, PT in the spring of 2007 I had the Sopromar Yard
attempt to re-pack this stuffing box (it had begun a slight leak
after the Med Cruise in 2006). They also had great difficulty in
getting close enough to the gland to effectively clean out the old
packing material. They removed as much as they could then put in as
much fresh packing as would fit.
|